The modifiable areal unit problem maup is one of the betterknown problems in geography and spatial analysis. Edit any pdf file, including all images, paragraphs, and pages. Metrics of urban form and the modifiable areal unit. Using geographic information systems to create and analyze.
These issues, together known as the modifiable areal unit problem, are well known in geography. Seeking the preferred areal unit for health geography. Indeed, openshaw 1984 and others have shown that the results of statistical analysis may differ wildly according to the scale and pattern of the areal units used. Among them, modifiable areal units and boundary problems are directly or. This work presents a nonparametric statistical test, smaup, to measure the sensitivity of a spatially intensive variable to the effects of the modifiable areal unit problem maup. At the same time, the conceptualization of place at the local scale is one of the weakest theoretical aspects in health geography. However analysis undertaken on such data is not independent of how these areal units are configured. Neighborhoods, daily activities, and measuring health risks experienced in urban environments. This issue of choice of resolution in environmental justice analysis is associated with what is referred to as the modifiable areal unit problem maup. Incorporating geography into a new generalized theoretical. The modifiable areal unit problem maup is a source of statistical bias that can significantly impact the results of statistical hypothesis tests. The probability that an event will occur is higher with larger spatial units. An introduction to the modifiable areal unit problem. The modifiable areal unit problem refers to the modifications of any statistical analysis when changing the scale of observation e.
Local and regional effects spatial autocorrelation local processes identifying processes scales and areal zones deriving data to reflect the processes where does this leave us. These specific links are not active in other sections of the website. The modifiable areal unit problem maup is a source of statistical bias that is common in spatially aggregated data, or data grouped into regions or districts where only summary statistics are produced within each district, especially where the districts chosen are not suitable for the data. The modifiable areal unit problem maup raises issues when census. Bhat 2006, neighborhood representation in residential location choice analysis, compendium of papers cdrom, transportation research board 85 th annual meeting, washington d. The modifiable areal unit problem in precision agriculture.
The modifiable areal unit problem in regional economics core. The modifiable areal unit problem in regional economics. Therefore, in the telecoupled global land use system, country. The modifiable area unit problem maup occurs when the spatial zoning system used to collect andor analyze geographic data is modifiable or arbitrary. Pdf effects of the modifiable areal unit problem on the delineation. The modifiable areal unit problem maup in the relationship. To be more precise, the word modifiable in maup contains two related but distinctive components.
There is growing interest in incorporating urban form indicators into transportation planning and travel analysis. In 1934, openshaw illustrates that real units zonal objects used in many geographical studies are arbitrary, modifiable, and subject to the whims and fancies of whoever is doing, or did, the aggregating. This research paper focuses on the application of geographic information system gis technologies and spatial regressive modeling techniques analyzing data at a variety of different geographic aggregations to examine the impact of the modifiable areal unit problem s maup openshaw and taylor 1979 impact on the results of criminological research. Pdf transportation analysis is typically thought of as one kind of spatial. Street as a big geodata assembly and analysis unit in. The modifiable areal unit problem in a repression model whose independent variable is a distance from a predetermined point naoto tagashira, atsuyuki okabe geographical analysis, volume 34, number 1, january 2002, pp. These indicators typically are measured at a certain level of spatial aggregation e. Spatial unit size and probability problem probabilities tend to be larger with larger spatial units. Statistical test to measure the sensitivity to the modifiable. Detecting spatial movement of intraregion crime patterns.
Area units used in population health studies should be delineated so as to represent the a priori scale of the expected scale interaction between neighbourhood. For example, in the art section you will instead see links leading to other art sections in the 2nd row of the navigation menu. Maup affects results when pointbased measures of spatial phenomena are aggregated into districts, for example, population density or illness rates. Investigating neighbourhood boundaries and health why does it happen. The process of defining or creating management zones would be acceptable if it were performed using a fixed set of rules or if there were some geographically meaningful basis for creating them. The modifiable area unit problem maup can cause differences in the. In each of these cases, the absolute descriptive statistics of an area the mean, median, mode, standard deviation, and variation are changed through the manipulation of these spatial problems. You are using a new version of the igi global website. All agreements must be in accordance with the arizona residential landlord and tenant act. There are several potential difficulties associated with the analysis of spatial data, among these are boundary delineation, modifiable areal units, and the level of spatial aggregation or scale. Spatial and temporal changes in prevalence of obesity. Arizona rental contracts, for commercial and residential use, are written for the binding arrangement between a landlord and tenant for the use of real property. The paper focuses on the issue of the modifiable areal unit problem, which means a possibility of obtaining various results for spatial economic analyses depending on the assumed composition of territorial units. All analyses of spatially aggregated data are vulnerable to the modifiable areal unit problem maup, which describes the sensitivity of analytical results to the arbitrary choice of spatial aggregation unit at which data are measured.
Spatial research has been plagued by the modifiable areal unit problem, or maup openshaw, 1979, for decades. In other words, it is the probability of not committing a type ii error. In this paper the examination of the modifiable areal unit problem is extended into multivariate statistical analysis. Citeseerx detecting spatial movement of intraregion. Neighborhoods, daily activities, and measuring health. Many canadian population health studies, including those focusing on the relationship between exposure to air pollution and health, have operationalized neighbourhoods at the census tract scale. The scale effect is the variations in results that may be obtained when the same areal data are combined into sets of increasingly larger areal units of analysis. Apparent patterns both spatial and statistical in the data are caused by the choice of district. Neighborhood, residential location choice, modifiable areal unit problem. The maup is a serious problem endemic to analyses of spatially aggregated data in all scientific disciplines.
Pdf how serious is the modifiable areal unit problem for. In an investigation of the parameter estimates from a multiple linear regression model and a multiple logit regression model, conclusions are drawn about the sensitivity of such estimates to variations in scale and zoning systems. Convert pdf files to and from any microsoft office formaton the desktop with nitro pro or in any web browser with nitro cloud. Pdf an information statistical approach to the modifiable areal unit. A major point of departure in understanding problems is the recognition that. Statistical test to measure the sensitivity to the. Modifiable temporal unit problem mtup and its effect on. Maup modifiable areal unit problem, traffic modeling.
Gis abstract transportation analysis is typically thought as one kind of spatial analysis. This has been expressed as the modifiable areal unit problem maup. When aggregating data in geographical information science analytical circles, one of the pitfalls of statistically analyzing geographic information is the modifiable areal unit. Tooffertwoexamples from recent literature, one view 21, 22 sees niche as the joint. The major research objective of the work is to examine the scale problem that constitutes one of the aspects of the modifiable areal unit problem. The effects of mtup on the detection of spacetime clusters of crime datasets of central london are examined using spacetime scan statistics stss. Capturing the impacts of land use on travel behavior. The modifiable areal unit problem in traffic safety. In particular most are unable to determine any change in spatial crime pattern within an areal unit. The modifiable areal unit problem, which is a potential source of error, arises when an identified geographic pattern is partly a consequence of the size and shape of the areal units used in the study.
Pdf the modifiable areal unit problem maup in the relationship. Ver hoef and cressie 1993, local image variation graphs in. To the best of our knowledge, smaup is the first statistic of its type and focuses on determining how much the distribution of the variable, at its highest level of spatial disaggregation, will change when it is. In other words, scale andor the zoning design considerations that. However, beside the rich tradition in the empirical spatial data analysis, the effect of maup on putting forward and testing a theory and the effect on modelbuilding is an issue rarely investigated.
Gadm database for global administrative areas, version 2. Most statistical work using modifiable areal unit data is deficient because zonal system doesnt fit processes and probably underestimates the strength of relationships statistical results are not independent of the zonal systems the data come from probably worth analysing data at several. An xls file there has been a great deal of interest in the v. A limitation of the map was that it was subject to changes in spatial scale, usually described as the modifiable areal unit. Exploring the modifiable areal unit problem in spatial water.
Small areal units tend to have very low frequencies for random events unless the event is extremely common. Effects of modifiable areal units on destination choice sets in the context of activitybased models of urban travel demand. To ensure that the 500km radius was not restricted, a cluster was allowed to contain up to 50% of the population at risk of overweightobesity in china. Effects of maup on spatial econometric models springerlink. Modifiable areal unit problem, scale, aggregation, spatial analysis, deforestation drivers. A problem or a matter of perception in the context of residential location choice modeling. Pdf the modifiable areal unit problem becomes apparent when incidence. Noise levels for grid dimensions smaller than 1400 m are very high greater than. Spatial distribution of human population in france.
Bhat the university of texas at austin, department of civil engineering. Scott center for spatial analysis, school of geography and earth sciences, mcmaster university, hamilton, ontario, canada, l8s 4k1. In a previous work arbia in spatial data configuration in the statistical analysis of regional economics and related problems, kluwer, dordrecht. In other words, the results vary according to the spatial zoning which is used in the study. Recent advances in spatial science and technology have exacerbated the effects of the maup prevalent in many. Since the spatial units are arbitrary, the results from the analysis based on these units may be arbitrary, that is, an artifact of the spatial. This phenomenon illustrates both the need for considering space in ones analysis, and the fundamental uncertainties that accompany realworld analysis. The modifiable areal unit problem in a repression model. Areal homogeneity and the modifiable areal unit problem. Developing a flexible framework for spatiotemporal population. Gis, modifiable spatiotemporal unit problem, population. In other words, if you know the location of one point and know the nature of. The maup can be broken down into two categories, the scale or aggregation effect and the zoning or grouping effect.
Pdf the modifiable areal unit problem in traffic safety. The modifiable areal unit problem maup raises issues when census tracts are used as neighbourhood proxies, and no other alternate spatial structure is used. All documents become legally binding upon all parties signing the form and acceptance being relayed to the other party unless both parties sign. Methods in analogy to maup, the modifiable temporal unit problem mtup is defined as consisting of three temporal effects aggregation, segmentation and boundary. What is modifiable areal unit problem maup igi global.
Basic issue, potential solutions and future research article pdf available in journal of traffic and transportation engineering 51. Scale effects on spatially embedded contact networks arxiv. In 1985, the prevalence of overweightobesity among boys was highest in beijing 2. Rsai05 scott modifiable areal units universite laval. Words in the wsj corpus are mapped to named entity clusters and a. This problem is mostly called modifiable areal unit problem maup. These factors limit the degree to which results from different metacommunity and macro. The modifiable areal unit problem and gerrymandering the. Usually studies measure the change in crime levels in contiguous areas expressed as discrete subdivisions of a study area, but this can become problematic due to difficulties such as the modifiable areal unit problem maup. The first step is to state explicitly what is meant by the word niche.
1335 116 1228 264 1446 1319 579 1316 3 249 1194 1331 1481 1410 900 681 1145 1332 860 446 162 419 406 931 1157 497 301 1235 1038 815 558 1378 1038 690 1152 930 1334 41 1476